Ask The Muscle Prof: What's The Best Cardio For Preserving Mass?

You've heard the benefits of high-intensity cardio for weight loss, but you're concerned it'll cost you hard-earned muscle. Learn the truth!
Q
I hear people talking about high-intensity cardio constantly these days, but I still know a lot of guys who slog away for hours doing low-intensity work. I just want whichever one that won't cut into my gains! What should I do?

One of the undeniable hallmarks of bodybuilding is extreme muscularity. The other is razor-sharp conditioning. Look at pretty much everybody's program, and you'll see how they approach these two goals: resistance training to build mass, followed by some cardio to burn fat. Simple enough, right?

The science backs up the effectiveness of these two modalities. It's where they mix, in "concurrent training," that things get complicated. For instance, a study published in the Journal of Applied Physiology in 1998 found that 10 weeks of resistance training plus cardio resulted in greater fat loss than lifting weights alone. Unfortunately, in that same study, strength gains were cut in half when cardio was added to weightlifting.1 Other studies have similarly found that muscle growth is severely decreased when cardio is integrated into a program.2,3

There are a number of explanations as to why cardio blunts gains. One is that cardio adds extra volume to your training, making it difficult to recover from normal lifting.4 Other researchers maintain that the physiological adaptations that follow cardio training are the complete opposite of those which occur with lifting weights, and that cardiovascular gains are thus capable of cancelling out gains from weight training.5

Both of these scenarios imply that mass-seekers are paddling upstream when they begin trying to cut fat. So is it really impossible to maximize the positive effects of cardio, while eliminating the negative? My colleagues at the University of Tampa and I have been studying this question in recent years, and we have some good news for you: It is possible. It all depends on what type of cardio you choose, and how much of it you perform.

Pedal Away from the Treadmill ///

One of our recent studies investigated the effects that different types of cardio, their intensity, and the separation of cardio from lifting had on muscle size.6 The goal was to determine exactly which components of cardio are detrimental to resistance training results. For instance, when we compared cycling to running, we found that running caused far greater declines in muscle growth than cycling. This echoed a 2009 study in another lab which found that uphill walking produced greater decrements in strength than cycling.7

There are a couple of explanations for why this is the case. The first is that the range of motion you use when jogging or incline walking is so dissimilar from lifting weights—squatting, for instance—that it impairs strength gains in those lifts. Unlike running, however, cycling has a large range of motion at the knee and hips.

Another theory is that cycling is mainly a concentric movement and causes little muscle damage, whereas running causes a lot of muscle damage from its eccentric and elongation portions.8 This would make it easier to recover from cycling than from running.

The Importance of Intensity ///

Intensity and duration have an even greater effect than mode. Our study concluded that long-term fat loss is actually lowest with moderate intensity, long-duration cardio. The greatest fat loss actually occurred with the shortest duration and highest-intensity activities, like sprinting. We also saw that the longer you do cardio per day, the greater the losses are in muscle mass. However, we found very small decreases in muscle and strength when cardio was kept to less than 20 minutes per day.

"But what about the 'fat-burning zone?'" you shout from the treadmill! By this, you refer to a study conducted in the early 1990s by Dr. Romijn, who concluded that we use the most fat during exercise when performing moderate intensity (65 percent heart rate max), long-duration (45-60 minutes) cardio.9 This study's conclusions are reflected in the "fat-burning" programs on nearly every cardio machine at the gym. However, a major problem with the study is that what happens during exercise does not always reflect what will occur long term. I want to hammer this point home.

My lab recently conducted another experiment where we compared low-intensity, long-duration cardio of 60 minutes with 4-10 sets of 10-30-second all-out sprints. As expected, we found that long duration cardio decreased muscle size. But get this: Sprinting actually increased size.10 This suggests that sprinting can actually be anabolic and get you shredded at the same time!

Put it All Together ///

OK, I know many of you are thinking right now: "If this is true, then why do so many bodybuilders have success with long-duration, low-intensity cardio? It seems to work for them…" I reply that the question is not whether long-duration cardio can help you lose fat—it can—but rather what you as an athlete need to do in order to optimize your training and reach your goals as efficiently as possible. In this case, the research is clear: High-intensity sprinting leads to greater fat loss than low-intensity, while also maintaining and possibly increasing muscle mass.

That being said, sprinting isn't easy to get started with, so it's necessary to approach it methodically. Bodybuilders seeking fat loss should try performing 10-30 second all-out sprints for between 4 and 10 reps. When I say "all-out," I mean you should feel like you are going to puke at the end of the sprint. However, I recommend beginning at the lower range and working your way up.

Once you establish your conditioning, which will likely take at least a month, you should begin to periodize your sprinting protocols. For example, if you do three sprinting sessions per week, I recommend one to be shorter duration and really high intensity, such as six 10-second hill sprints. One could be moderate duration, such as six 15-second sprints on flat ground. And finally, one should be longer, such as four 30-second all-out cycling sprints. I'm also a fan of balls-to-wall activities like car pushes and prowler or sled pushes and pulls.

Finally, try to separate your cardio from leg days by at least a day. Our lab and others have found that the effects of cardio are specific to the muscle worked. So if you do leg-intensive cardio today, it will directly affect muscle growth in your legs. What research shows clearly is that cardio ideally should be separated from legs by at least 24 hours. Otherwise you risk impairing your gains.11

That may sound like a lot of guidelines, but just think about all the time you're saving by not spending hour after hour on the treadmill. It's definitely worth a little bit of extra planning.



References

  1. Dolezal, B.A. and J.A. Potteiger, Concurrent resistance and endurance training influence basal metabolic rate in nondieting individuals. J Appl Physiol, 1998. 85(2): p. 695-700.
  2. Bell, G.J., et al., Effect of concurrent strength and endurance training on skeletal muscle properties and hormone concentrations in humans. Eur J Appl Physiol, 2000. 81(5): p. 418-27.
  3. Kraemer, W.J., et al., Compatibility of high-intensity strength and endurance training on hormonal and skeletal muscle adaptations. J Appl Physiol, 1995. 78(3): p. 976-89.
  4. Hickson, R.C., Interference of strength development by simultaneously training for strength and endurance. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup Physiol, 1980. 45(2-3): p. 255-63.
  5. Hakkinen, K., et al., Neuromuscular adaptations during concurrent strength and endurance training versus strength training. Eur J Appl Physiol, 2003. 89(1): p. 42-52.
  6. Wilson, J.M., et al., Concurrent training: a meta-analysis examining interference of aerobic and resistance exercises. Journal of strength and conditioning research / National Strength & Conditioning Association, 2012. 26(8): p. 2293-307.
  7. Gergley, J.C., Comparison of two lower-body modes of endurance training on lower-body strength development while concurrently training. J Strength Cond Res, 2009. 23(3): p. 979-87.
  8. Koller, A., et al., Effects of prolonged strenuous endurance exercise on plasma myosin heavy chain fragments and other muscular proteins. Cycling vs running. J Sports Med Phys Fitness, 1998. 38(1): p. 10-7.
  9. Romijn, J.A., et al., Regulation of endogenous fat and carbohydrate metabolism in relation to exercise intensity and duration. Am J Physiol, 1993. 265(3 Pt 1): p. E380-91.
  10. Naimo, M.A., et al., High Intensity Interval Training Has Positive Effects on Skeletal Muscle Hypertrophy, Power, and On-Ice Performance. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, Conference Proceedings, 2013.
  11. Sale, D.G., et al., Comparison of two regimens of concurrent strength and endurance training. Med Sci Sports Exerc, 1990. 22(3): p. 348-56.

Bookmark and Share

Related Articles

About The Author

Dr. Jacob Wilson, Ph.D., CSCS*D is a professor and director of the skeletal muscle and sports nutrition laboratory at the University of Tampa.

RATE THIS ARTICLE
POOR
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
EXCELLENT
OVERALL RATING
8.5

Out of 10
Excellent
205 Ratings

133

Comments

Showing 1 - 25 of 133 Comments

(5 characters minimum)

      • notify me when users reply to my comment
Mudvayne24

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
Mudvayne24

Thank you for your research Dr. Wilson. I look forward to all of the Muscle College Radio sessions that are up and coming. You and Layne are great when it comes to really explaining the science and how it applies directly to the specific activities within our bodies. I currently do 0% cardio in my routine and it's great to know that I don't have to waste countless hours on a treadmill to try and burn off some extra fat. Keep the science coming!

Aug 1, 2013 6:24pm | report
 
DrJacobWilson

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
DrJacobWilson

Thanks buddy, I really appreciate it!!!!!

Aug 1, 2013 8:21pm | report
hart1em

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
hart1em

I usually do short cardio after lifting, is it better to do it before?

Aug 1, 2013 6:35pm | report
 
DrJacobWilson

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
DrJacobWilson

If you are doing legs its best to separate by at least a day. On upper body days if you do sprints, do them after because you should be faint afterwards

Aug 1, 2013 8:22pm | report
Psychomania

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
Psychomania

before and after

Aug 2, 2013 10:58am | report
Janskistar

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
Janskistar

I always heard it was better after, once glycogen in your liver is depleted.

Aug 4, 2013 4:14pm | report
faiznmatazzz

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
faiznmatazzz

Thank you Dr. Wilson.

Article Rated:
Aug 1, 2013 6:43pm | report
 
DrJacobWilson

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
DrJacobWilson

You bet!

Aug 1, 2013 8:22pm | report
XxmetallicaxX

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
XxmetallicaxX

another way to look at it is just worry about getting the fat off all at once with lifting and lots of cardio an then when you've cut to where you want to be worry about bulking up or getting gains after, its much harder to do it all at once as this article suggests, doesn't mean you have to stop cardio altogether.....

Aug 1, 2013 7:34pm | report
 
DrJacobWilson

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
DrJacobWilson

I definitely understand your points. The main thesis of the article though was even when you are dieting to get cut, to do the high intensity cardio, and then you won't have to worry as much about losing the muscle you gained during your bulk.

Aug 1, 2013 8:24pm | report
DrJacobWilson

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
DrJacobWilson

FYI Metallica is my favorite band ever

Aug 1, 2013 8:24pm | report
Peter LeDrew

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
Peter LeDrew

Awesome job again Dr. Wilson!!! Thank you!

Aug 1, 2013 10:28pm | report
 
BigBadHarv

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
BigBadHarv

Hi Dr. Wilson,

How long should the rest periods be between sets/reps?

Thanks.

Article Rated:
Aug 1, 2013 10:56pm | report
 
DrJacobWilson

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
DrJacobWilson

Hey bud, 2-4 minutes depending on your conditioning. You should need every second to recover as well

Aug 2, 2013 8:37am | report
StackDBack

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
StackDBack

Common rest to run ratio is 4:1 for beginning, 3:1 intermediate, 2:1 advanced and short burst (ie. sprint 10 seconds, rest 40 seconds). Sets/Reps can be 30x30meters, 10x100m, 6-8x200m, 3-4x400m; also timed sprints on an incline 8x10sec, 6x20sec, 4x30 seconds. Also, do 1 long, slow run a week for recovery (ie. 3-6miles).

Aug 6, 2013 10:41am | report
BigBadHarv

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
BigBadHarv

Thank you both for the great advice.

Aug 12, 2013 11:14pm | report
MBDonegan

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
MBDonegan

If you've reached the low end of the body fat world and want to do a clean, slow bulk at like 250 calories surplus, would it be inadvisable to do 3 days of cardio at about 30 minutes after the upper body lifting days? Would it be better to shift it to 20 minutes while doing a clean bulk? Or none at all? I always thought at least some cardio was better for gains than absolutely none, but I'm not sure

Aug 1, 2013 11:28pm | report
 
DrJacobWilson

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
DrJacobWilson

Hey buddy, I would do a total of 1-2 minutes of cardio (not including rest periods) 3 xs per week. So you might do 6 10 second sprints, or 2 30 second sprints. Total time with rest definately shouldnt exceed 20 mins.
That will keep your insulin sensitivity very high, and help partition nutrients away from fat and towards muscle

Aug 2, 2013 8:39am | report
JABE00

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
JABE00

Always did cardio every two weeks and always on legs days, going to have to rethink according to this.

Aug 2, 2013 2:55am | report
 
NatAlt

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
NatAlt

Having a 'fat burning zone' on most cardio equipment has been culturally damaging IMO, so I'm glad you raised it here doc. If only the general gym-going public could be informed.

Perhaps it's the duty of every bodybuilder to heave their heft over to someone slogging it on the treadmill and enlighten them. I don't see how this plan could possibly go wrong.

Aug 2, 2013 3:23am | report
 
DrJacobWilson

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
DrJacobWilson

NatAlt I completely agree!

Aug 2, 2013 8:39am | report
Nobilis

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
Nobilis

From time to time I have debate about cardio: after or before workout, interval or external, intesive or low intensity is best for us? I always did intensive and short cardio sessions, about 10 to 20 minutes after workout.
But I never ever thought I should sprint for 10 secons with as few reps as 4-10! This is so... unorthodox! These sprints are more strength training than cardio training, IMO. Also, it can not be done with a cardio machine.
However, I am going to give a chance it, indeed!

Aug 2, 2013 5:07am | report
 
DrJacobWilson

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
DrJacobWilson

Its crazy I know! Sprinting outside and doing hills works great. Using the stationary bike works well too

Aug 2, 2013 8:40am | report
BaBbu38

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
BaBbu38

Is it true that morning empty stomach cardio and weight training help us to loss excessive body fat?

Aug 2, 2013 6:39am | report
 
zabetak

Rep Power: 0

  • rep this user
zabetak

This is indeed an interesting question with many answers. I am trying this for almost two weeks now (20min cardio every morning separate from weight training ) and it seems to work, but still it is early. Probably an answer from an expert would be very much appreciated:)

Aug 2, 2013 7:14am | report
  • Body Stats
  • ht: 5'10"
  • wt: 164.24 lbs
  • bf: 13.1%
Showing 1 - 25 of 133 Comments

Featured Product