Ask The Protein Chef: Got A Simple Protein Ice Cream Recipe?

I have a passion for weightlifting, nutrition, and great-tasting food. My specialty is cooking with protein powder. Ask me a question and I'll turn it into a protein-filled, delicious recipe!

I love vanilla ice cream but don't eat it because it's so high in sugar and fat. Is it possible to make a healthy, high-protein version using basic ingredients?

I started experimenting with protein ice cream at because I love ice cream and found the idea of eating a healthy version really exciting. I thought it would be especially good served on top of a fresh stack of post-workout protein pancakes!

I went through a lot of trials and errors with my protein ice cream, but eventually arrived at what is so far my favorite formula. The recipe is simple and calls for only three ingredients. But the best part is that it doesn't require an ice cream machine.

Are you ready to get your ice cream on?

Protein Ice Cream

  1. Using a food processor, handheld blender, or mixer, blend all ingredients together. Don't use a whisk or spoon because the aim is to end up with a mixture that's creamy, not lumpy.

  2. Place the mixture in a Tupperware container and stick it in the freezer for an hour.
  3. After an hour, remove the container and give the ice cream a good stir. You want to make sure that it freezes evenly. Think of yourself as a human ice cream machine.

  4. Put container back in the freezer. Wait for another hour before taking it out and giving it another churn.

  5. Repeat steps three and four until the ice cream is nicely set and ready to be munched with gusto.


Since there's a lot of churning involved, I like making this on the weekend. I wake up, make the mixture, stick it in the freezer, take it out to churn, put to back in, go to the gym, come back, give it another couple churns and … pow! It's ready.

This recipe works with casein or protein blends—it makes the ice cream even creamier! If you use other types of protein, you may have to add a couple of tablespoons of milk to the mix if it's too thick.

Try using vanilla protein powder, and try adding vanilla extract or shaved vanilla pod for an even richer vanilla flavor. You can also add some Walden Farms calorie-free caramel sauce to your ice-cream.

For an insanely tasty, guilt-free dessert, try making protein crepes and topping them with protein ice cream. It tastes like a cheat meal, but it is packed with protein!

This recipe serves two people so feel free to duplicate it. If you do, you'll just have to leave your mix in the freezer for longer so it gets the right consistency.

Nutrition Facts
Serving Size Per serving, recipe serves 2
Amount per serving
Calories 258
Total Fat4.8g
Total Carbs17g

Protein Ice Cream PDF (69.1 KB)

Recommended For You

Ask The Protein Powder Chef: Do You Have A Recipe For Chocolaty Christmas Cookies?

Santa's going to need strength to lead that sleigh. This year, leave him chocolate cookies that pack a protein punch!

Ask The Protein Powder Chef: Low Carb Peanut Butter Protein Cookies

Savor the flavor of a creamy, melt-in-your-mouth cookie full of peanut buttery goodness. Choosy moms might choose Jif, but protein lovers choose these low-carb cookies!

Ask The Protein Powder Chef: Do You Have A Recipe For Protein Brownies?

No one wants to bite into a fresh baked good only to find it rubbery, tough, and inedible. Whip up these brownies instead. They're smooth, sweet, and protein-packed.