Does Fruit Make You Fat?
The old adage that your body is a temple is well known and still has relevance today. Without a solid foundation a temple cannot be successfully constructed and will eventually collapse. The same holds true for the human body. We at ISSA strive to educate our trainers regarding the synergism between proper exercise, nutrition and behavior modification to effectively draw their clientele into not just a good lifestyle, or even a better lifestyle, but the best way of life; a fitness lifestyle.
The importance of nutrition is imperative as the foundation of any successful fitness program. The core of this foundation should be based around food. Just as certain compounds are necessary to build a solid foundation in a building, specific foods are necessary to build a solid nutritional foundation. Since we have already discussed which foods aid in building this foundation through past articles, we will focus our attention on why certain foods that are considered healthy, actually may not aid in fat reduction.
Why Fruits Are Important!
With the advent of so many nutritional approaches to achieve the ideal look, numerous inquiries regarding the practice of omitting fruit, fruit juices or any of its derivatives from a diet have surfaced. Fruit is a healthy food, full of nutrients, high in fiber, vitamins, minerals, and low in fat and calories. It is a common practice for bodybuilders during pre-contest preparation to omit fruit from their diets, as it should be for anyone looking to minimize body fat. We will discuss the chemistry behind the efficacy of this practice.
Our bodies can only absorb monosaccharides (glucose, galactose, or fructose), the single units of sugars and starches. Once absorbed through the small intestines into the portal vein, and then circulated into the bloodstream through the liver as blood glucose, our bodies can put glucose to work in three ways.
The Three Ways Our Bodies Put Glucose To Work
- It can burn the glucose immediately for energy if blood glucose levels are not at a stable level of 20 grams blood borne glucose circulating per hour.
- If it is not needed for energy immediately, then it is converted into glycogen in the liver or muscles. The liver has the capacity to store 100 grams of glycogen. The muscles have the capacity to store between 250-400 grams of glycogen, depending on muscle mass and physical condition. Liver glycogen supplies energy for the entire body. Muscle glycogen only supplies energy to muscles.
- If the body has an excess of glucose, and all of the glycogen stores are full, the surplus glucose is converted to fat by the liver and stored as adipose tissue (bodyfat) around the body. If needed, fatty acids can be burned as fuel (BUT the fat cannot be converted back to glucose).
Now that we have outlined how our bodies use glucose, we will discuss why fruit (fructose or fruit sugar) is detrimental in an attempt to maximize fat loss. Since muscles have the specific purpose of contraction, they have a limited number of enzymes for glycogen synthesis. Muscle only has the necessary enzymes to convert glucose (and nothing else) into glycogen. The liver, however, is able to make glycogen from fructose, lactate, glycerol, alanine, and other three-carbon metabolites. Muscle glycogen, which is similar in structure to starch, is an amylopectin (branched chained polymer containing hundreds of glucose units). Unlike muscles, which can only supply energy to themselves through the stored 250-400 grams of glycogen, the liver is responsible for supplying energy to the entire body.
If You Have Fruit Or Fruit Juice The Following Conditions Occur
Referring to the three ways the body uses glucose, assuming that blood glucose levels are adequate, the glucose will then be stored as glycogen. Muscle does not have the necessary enzymes to synthesize fructose into glycogen; therefore the liver converts this fructose into liver glycogen. It would only take three, 8-ounce glasses of orange juice to fully replenish liver glycogen stores. Since the liver is responsible for supplying energy to the entire body, once its stores are full, a rate limiting enzyme in glucose metabolism, which is responsible for signaling the body to store glucose as glycogen or convert it to fat (phosphofructokinase), signals the body that all stores are full. If the glycogen stores are signaled as full, then the third way our body uses excess glucose is to convert it to fatty acids and store as adipose tissue. In essence, fruit sugar is easily converted to fat.
Many may be asking why then is fruit low on the glycemic index? If it does not cause a sudden release of insulin, then how could it ever be a poor food choice? Once the fructose (fruit sugar) enters the liver and liver glycogen is already full, then it cannot be used by the muscles for glycogen or energy production.
It is converted to fat and released back into the bloodstream to be stored as adipose tissue. The low glycemic response is based on the fact that fructose leaves the liver as fat, and fat does not raise insulin levels.
This is the biochemistry behind the recommendations to limit fruit in your diet. As mentioned, fruit is a very nutritious food full of vitamins, minerals, fiber, and low in calories and fat. If your goal is to exclusively to minimize bodyfat, then it is advisable that you consume more complex carbohydrates, which will go to replenishing muscle glycogen stores rather than fruit, which will only replenish liver glycogen stores, and is useless in muscle glycogen replenishment.
- Costill DL, Sherman WM, Fink WJ, Witten MW, and Miller JM. The role of dietary carbohydrates in muscle glycogen resynthesis after strenuous running. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 34: 1831-1836, 1981.
- Shafrir E. Fructose/sucrose metabolism, its physiological and pathological implications. Sugars and Sweeteners, Kretchmer N and Hollenbeck CB, Eds. CRC Press, 1991pp. 63-98.
- Herbert V, Subak-Sharpe GJ. Total Nutrition: The Only Guide You'll Ever Need. St Martins Press, 1987 pp. 54-55.
- Follow This Discussion by:
Anyone saying that fruit makes you fat has a ***** loose. EVERY single cell in our entire body runs off of carbs, fructose from real natural fruit is your best bet. "Studies" that have been done to "prove" fruit makes you fat used high fructose corn syrup to prove this point. However, fresh fruit does not equal high fructose corn syrup.
My understanding is that just because fructose is not converted to glucose-6-phosphate and consequently glycogen in skeletal muscle does not mean that fructose is more likely to be converted to fat. While it is true that the liver is the only place fructose can be processed, the fact remains that the liver will break down its glycogen stores based on blood sugar levels via the enzyme glucose-6-phosphatase. Therefore if the skeletal muscles are burning through glucose causing a decrease in blood sugar levels the liver will burn through its glycogen stores in order to release glucose and overall lead to no more fat gain than if someone were to eat equal amounts of glucose as opposed to fructose. The main problem with excess fructose consumption, however, is the stress that is put on the liver if it is constantly being used to store fructose as glycogen or convert it to glucose to release in the blood stream.
OMGoodness, I'm now very confused. I eat fruit like 3x daily. How often should I have it if that's the case. I saw a trainer on here suggest berries in the morning and 1 banana in the afternoon. HELP!!!
I too have been very confused by this phenomenon and have been doing lots of research to clarify things for myself. So far this is my understanding. The liver must process fructose before it can be used by the body as energy . It treats the fructose like a toxin much like the way it treats alcohol. The liver takes the fructose and using ketohexokinase and Aldo B its transformed into triglyceride. This is a fat. Once transformed this fat can be used as a source of energy. Well as we know fat is easily stored as fat. So is fruit bad? No. Not in excess. Processed fructose cornsyrup etc. Is definitely bad. But natural fruit should be limited to under 50 - 75g carbs 2- 3 servings max per day according to many researchers. If ur not cutting
Fruit is very healthy and nutritious and there is no real need to monitor vigorously how much you eat. 2 servings is easy to reach but like any food serving size is important. There is such thing as too much of a good thing but I wouldn't worry too much about eating fruit. I enjoy it as a snack if I am in the mood for it.